top of page
  • QuitSure Team

How Effective are the 7 FDA-Approved Tobacco Cessation Medications? A Comparative Analysis

Updated: Jun 7, 2023

Tobacco addiction is a global health issue, and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved seven medications to combat this problem. But how effective are these medications? Let's take a deep dive into the stats, facts, and comparative analysis of these seven tobacco cessation medications.

Nicotine Gum (Nicorette)

Nicotine gum works by releasing nicotine which is absorbed through the lining of your mouth, helping to curb cravings. The gum comes in two doses: 2 mg for those who smoke less than 25 cigarettes a day, and 4 mg for those who smoke 25 or more cigarettes a day. Studies have shown that nicotine gum can double the success rate of quitting smoking when compared to a placebo.

Nicotine Lozenge

Like the gum, the lozenge also releases nicotine absorbed in the mouth. It's meant to be used every one to two hours, and the dosage depends on your smoking habits. According to research, the nicotine lozenge can increase the chances of quitting by 50% to 70% compared to a placebo.

Nicotine Patch (NicoDerm CQ)

The nicotine patch is a type of transdermal patch that releases a steady flow of nicotine into the bloodstream through the skin. Its efficacy varies, but on average, the patch can increase quit rates by 50% to 70%.

Nicotine Nasal Spray

Nicotine nasal spray delivers nicotine to the bloodstream rapidly, mimicking the speed of nicotine delivery from smoking. However, it can have side effects such as nose and throat irritation. Studies show that the nasal spray can double the chances of quitting successfully.

Nicotine Inhaler

The nicotine inhaler resembles a cigarette, allowing the user to mimic the hand-to-mouth ritual of smoking, while also providing a nicotine hit. This dual benefit may explain why it can double the quit rates compared to a placebo.

Varenicline (Chantix)

Varenicline works differently from nicotine-based medications. It works by reducing cravings and decreasing the pleasurable effects of tobacco products. Studies suggest that it can triple the chances of quitting successfully.

Bupropion (Zyban)

Bupropion is an antidepressant that has been found to help with smoking cessation, possibly by increasing the levels of certain brain chemicals. According to research, bupropion can double the quit rates.

While these medications can significantly improve the chances of quitting smoking, their effectiveness varies greatly from person to person. Factors such as how heavily a person smokes, their readiness to quit, and their level of addiction all play a role in the success of these medications. Additionally, these medications are most effective when combined with behavioral therapies or support programs.

As such, while these medications are effective in combating the physical addiction to nicotine, they do not address the psychological addiction that so often accompanies smoking. The act of smoking can be ritualistic; a break from work, a social event, or a coping mechanism for stress. These behavioral and psychological ties to smoking are not addressed by these medications.

For a more holistic approach, a combination of medication and behavioral therapy is often recommended. Behavioral therapies can help an individual identify their triggers and develop coping strategies, while support groups provide a community to share experiences and challenges. This combined approach can significantly increase the chances of successfully quitting smoking for good. It's not just about quitting nicotine; it's about changing habits and behaviors around smoking to ensure long-term success.

It's important to remember that quitting smoking is a journey, one that is often marked by setbacks. But with persistence, the right support, and the addressing of both chemical and psychological addictions, quitting smoking can become a reality. This comprehensive approach treats smoking addiction for what it truly is - not just a physical dependence on nicotine, but a complex interplay of habits, rituals, and coping mechanisms intertwined with nicotine use.

15 views0 comments


bottom of page